Bethlehem, His birthplace, represents the beginning of Christs earthly ministry, while Jerusalem represents the fulfilment of it. We could say that he is there simply because he was the first bishop of Ravenna. The number eight arises again in this context, linking the Abrahamic covenant with the Transfiguration and Resurrection: God commands the Israelites to circumcise all their males eight days after their birth (17:12). Bethlehem, His birthplace, represents the beginning of Christs earthly ministry, and Jerusalem the fulfilment of it. (A) built It embraces you. There's tremendous detail in God the Father ought not be depicted, for He was not incarnate. The Church can prophetically oppose a secular power that acts contrary to Gods commandments, but it can also accept material assistance from it if this genuinely aids the Churchs spiritual work and benefits peoples lives. God promised: I will establish my covenant as an everlasting covenant between me and you and your descendants after you for the generations to come, to be your God and the God of your descendants after you (Genesis 17:7). He's built this extraordinary church and here he would pray, here So the garden around Apollinare is the outcome of love and craft, and of God and man working together in synergy. Apse 6th century, triumphal arch 7th -12th century. The process is completed in transfiguration, a living light that knows no diminution in its sharing. The eighth day resurrection therefore takes human nature beyond the endless trapped cycle of the seven day week. This is graphically affirmed by two passages in the ancient hymn Exsultet, sung in the Western Church by a deacon in front of the Paschal candle. For the sake of completeness we can mention the date palms that stand either side of the apse. I think there are few examples of liturgical art that embody such a wide spectrum of Christs work as this mosaic at SantApollinare in Classe. This church contains magnificent mosaics depicting the teachings, miracles, Passion, and Resurrection of Christ; these are among the oldest such representations in existence and are. And St Iranaeus: Because of his boundless love, Jesus became what we are that he might make us to be what he is (Against Heresies, V). And when we looked down the nave, we see fabulous mosaics. They went up onto a mountain to pray. But we can delve deeper still into our mosaics other layers of meaning. Melchizedeks garment is identical to those worn by high priests Aaron in the third century fresco at Dura-Europos, and Caiaphas in the sixth century mosaic in nearby SantApollinare Nuovo, Aaron with the tabernacle. b. He stands behind an altar with two loaves and a chalice. - [Beth] These were foreigners. They delight the beholder immediately but at the same time possess layer upon layer of meaning, which reveal themselves only to the patient. In the centre is Christ in a medallion. Firstly, the apsidal dome mosaic is bounded by a broad decorative band. I think there are few examples of liturgical art that embody such a wide spectrum of Christs work as this mosaic at SantApollinare in Classe. These and other anomalies immediately invite us on a journey to try and discover their meaning. As a young man in my 30s, I beheld the beauty of this mosaic in Ravenna, contemplating all that appeared and for years trying to understand the conflation of imagery therein. to build a torch so precious.[2]. It depicts the priest King Melchezidek standing behind an altar with bread and wine, with Abel offering a lamb on his right, and Abraham offering Isaac on his left. Identify the following term or individual and explain their significance. This Mass names the Virgin Mary, male apostles, and saints, and seven female martyrs (each depicted in Ravenna's Basilica of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo): St. Felicitas, St. Perpetua, St. Agatha, St. Lucy, St. Agnes, St. Cecilia, and St. Anastasia. The passage reads: O holy Father, Ours is a seventh century work, but of poor quality, probably due to the multiple restorations it has suffered over the centuries. Mosaics of the basilica of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo. Christs transfiguration therefore indicates a return to this natural supernatural state of the human person. The upper tier: Christ and the four living creatures. And instead of the mountain of Tabor we have a garden. The brightly coloured clouds suggest the bright cloud that overshadowed them. This haloed saint stands in the midst of the garden, with his hands raised in prayer. It was reconsecrated in 561 AD, under the rule of the Byzantine emperor . The way that the holy bishop and martyr is set within the scene suggests that he has a broader significance. The union that this mosaic affirms is not just between God and man and matter, but also between the all faithful throughout time. They are independent, each with boundaries according to their God-given responsibilities, but each also assisting the other to fulfil Gods purpose. I suppose its like you said, Aidan: the root of the problem is a superficial spiritual life. We just don't know. The word began as an old Iranian word, paridayda, and signified a walled enclosure. Apollinaris of Ravenna (Italian: Apollinare; Greek: , Apollinarios, Late Latin: Apolenaris) is a Syrian saint, whom the Roman Martyrology describes as "a bishop who, according to tradition, while spreading among the nations the unsearchable riches of Christ, led his flock as a good shepherd and honoured the Church of Classis near Ravenna by a glorious martyrdom." (C) borrowed This theme of beginning and end is further alluded to by the depiction (executed in the 7th century) of Jerusalem and Bethlehem atop the triumphal arch. Palms traditionally represent paradise and a fruit bearing life. The Basilica of SantApollinare Nuovo was also erected by Theuderic. but in the fifth century they occupied Italy and And at the front of the The union that this mosaic affirms is not just between God and man and matter, but also between the all faithful throughout time. As St Athanasius, wrote, God became man, that we might become gods (On the Incarnation, 54:3). The shrubs, rocks and flowering plants are likewise arranged, with a perfect imperfection. In the Gospel of Matthew Christ tells us that at His coming again there will appear the sign of the Son of Man in heaven (Matthew 24:30). He's made Ravenna his capital. Stock Photo ID: 42200629 The platytera in the apse; pantokrator in the dome; etc, although of course traditional and significant, are not the only things we can put in our churches. Their authority therefore exists not to subjugate and oppress their medium, but to raise it up and make it even more articulate. This orb, encircled with a jewel-studded crown, hovers within a sky of gold and sunrise coloured clouds. As kings as well as priests, we are called not just to give thanks for all creation, but also to work within it to transform it like bees. Eternitys permanence will not be static but dynamic. There are in fact ninety-nine stars in our mosaic. Luke tells us that they were speaking about Christs departure about to be fulfilled in Jerusalem. Tradition has it that in 9th century the relics of . It's huge. On the left side are the secular authorities: the emperor and his brothers Heraclius and Tiberius, with a fourth figure holding a ciborium. Some of the Church Fathers say that Adam and Eve were in fact clothed with light before the fall, and only became naked when they turned from Gods way. Also, on either side of the great jewelled cross are three sheep. The mosaic is a profound theological discourse. This church contains magnificent mosaics depicting the teachings, miracles, Passion, and Resurrection of Christ; these are among the oldest such representations in existence and are campanile In campanile Write in the blank the linking verb in parentheses that agrees with the subject of each sentence. For the Greeks it became paradeisos, a park for animals. They were not Romans, Whom do you seek? Supposing him to be the gardener, she said to him, Sir, if you have carried him away, tell me where you have laid him, and I will take him away.. How do we know that this mosaic depicts the Transfiguration? Sometimes in the Gospel narratives people blurt out things that appear to be mistakes but end up being prophetical. So the garden of Eden becomes paradise. Set against this deep expanse the whiteness of the sheep and the saints garments seem brighter still. Wipf and Stock Publishers, 2004, page 19. Below Saint Apollinare, set between the windows, are mosaics of four previous bishops of Ravenna: Ecclesius (ECLESIVS), who was bishop of Ravenna from 522 to 532 and founder of San Vitale; Severus (SCS SEVERVS), a revered bishop of Ravenna in the 340s; Ursus (SCS VRSVS), bishop ca. The ultimate purpose of Christs incarnation was our own deification, our union with Him. There's that flat gold background that is typically Byzantine in style. Purple cloth was an imperial monopoly in Byzantium and therefore represents royalty. Christs parable of the lost sheep (Matthew 18:10-14) speaks of the shepherd leaving ninety-nine of his flock to find the one lost sheep. Either side of the crosss arms are the Greek letters Alpha and Omega, the first and last letters of the alphabet. So this hymn traces the stages from God-given nectar, to the work bees transforming nectar into honey and wax, followed by mans work to change the wax into candle. After he had communed with God and received the tablets of the law on Sinai, Moses had to leave the summit and descend back to the encamped Israelites. Each side are the four winged creatures, each holding a Gospel. I commend this study as a first to be done. When one sees it in the flesh it seems both vast and verdant. Excellent and informative, thank you very much. - [Steven] Their outfits are spectacular. Above the paradisiacal landscape with Apollinaris, on a golden background, the hand of God emerges from the white clouds. I hope to visit this basilica in 2018. One key to the deeper meaning of our mosaic is given in fact some days before the event of the Transfiguration itself. and the Christ child surrounded by four angels. We had work to do in paradise. - [Steven] The goths were Arian and the emperor in In Gods plan this royal and crafting role is inextricably tied to our priestly role, since in the Eucharist we offer not wheat and grapes, but bread and wine, which are the fruit of human labour. Thus the cross in our mosaic is golden and jewelled, to show that it is not only the instrument of the crucifixion but also the sign of conquest and transformation, the means by which Christ tramples down death by death. While the fleets of the unified Roman Empire faced few great naval threats, operating as a policing force vastly inferior in . The number ninety-nine appears again in the Bible and offers a second, complementary layer of meaning. This is graphically affirmed by two passages in the ancient hymn Exsultet, sung in the Western Church by a deacon in front of the Paschal candle. If you are doing the mosaics in Ravenna, don't forget to visit the church of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo which is also dazzling. Some of these themes were without doubt intended by the designer of the mosaic. The Basilica of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo is a UNESCO World Heritage site and is regarded as one of the most crucially important sites of Medieval Christian art in Europe. This is a sign of intercession and, most critically, the gesture used by the presiding bishop or priest at the epiclesis when, on behalf of all the faithful, he asks the Holy Spirit to come down upon us and these gifts here spread forth. The process of labour is thus completed in transfiguration, a living light that knows no diminution in its sharing. Global shipping available. The number eight arises again in this context, linking the Abrahamic covenant with the Transfiguration and Resurrection: God commands the Israelites to circumcise all their males eight days after their birth. (jazzy piano music). What does all this imagery mean? There's another frieze of large figures that are interrupted by the windows on the side of the church. To this paradise add animals, trees, birds, and a saint. Emperor Justinian, San Vitale, Ravenna, 6th century. Mosaic of Christ Enthroned with Angels, Basilica of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo, Ravenna, Italy: Date: 26 August 2011, 06:01: Source: Mosaic of Christ Enthroned with Angels, Basilica of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo, Ravenna, Italy: Author: Sharon Mollerus The mosaic was very colorful and had two Greek inscriptions that describe the ancient church fathers, who built the church for a martyr named "Theodoros." The mosaic was also covered in. This tier capitulates all that happens below. Nov 2019. The Ladder of Divine Ascent icon showing monks ascending to Jesus in Heaven, top right. The palace-church of Sant' But bees also represent communal transformative labour, since the work of the hive changes nectar into honey. I am a mosaicist myself, and have noticed that these smalti glass tesserae, especially the green ones, are somewhat more translucent than modern smalti. Our bishop Apollinare is a spiritual gardener as well as a priest. It was erected by the Ostrogothic king Theodoric the Great as his palace chapel during the first quarter of the 6th century (as attested to in the Liber Pontificalis ). It was erected by the Ostrogothic king Theodoric the Great as his palace chapel during the first quarter of the 6th century (as attested to in the Liber Pontificalis ). The Church is a priestly being, whose calling is to give thanks for all creation and to offer it to the Creator. The other one is in Rome, Santa Maria Maggiore. It is in fact a depiction of the Transfiguration of Christ, as described in the Gospel accounts of Matthew 17:1-8, Mark 9:2-8 and, most fully, in Luke 9:28-36. The passage reads: O holy Father,accept this candle, a solemn offering,the work of bees and of your servants hands,an evening sacrifice of praise,this gift from your most holy Church. But I would suggest that our cross also suggests the Ascension, or rather the words of the angels accompanying the Ascension: Men of Galilee, they said, why do you stand here looking into the sky? By association they also set everyone who worships in the basilica within the fellowship of all believers, past, present and future. The Creator in His turn transfigures and offers this world back to us. But everything about this apse suggests a schema extremely well thought out and multivalenced. Date palms, symbols of paradise, fruitfulness and victory. This is an appropriate scene, both because of the Holy Liturgy that is celebrated in front of it and because of our mosaics priestly and regal theme. RM 2K64CX4 - 19th century vintage photograph: The Basilica of Sant' Apollinare Nuovo is a basilica church in Ravenna, Italy. The mosaic gives us adumbrations of this cosmic transfiguration. By the 6th century BC the Assyrians had adopted it as pardesu, domain. Miracle of Loaves and Fishes (St. Apollinare Nuovo), top register; Christ in purple and gold, beardless; located in direct center to focus on majesty/divine nature; cruciform halo, and figure makes the shape of a cross; illusionistic blue sky is gone in favor of solid gold, but green ground is not; martyrs carry gold crowns, top register and middle built by Theodoric; top register depicts scenes from life of Christ; middle depicts Old Testament patriarchs or prophets; third is Byzantine style, depicting martyred saints, divided by gender, details and decorations (St. Apollinare Nuovo), mosaics in apse and arch are missing; capitals are more abstract/medieval, columns are imported; may have had a coffered ceiling, although the one there now is not original; Milanese masonry, iconic, figures are flat "cutouts", forms are stiff and anti-classical, frozen posture, garments of saints defy form, both naturalism of classical world and abstraction of Constantinian/Byzantium, returning to abstraction after classical revival, Early Christian, around 424, Ravenna; cross plan w/ aisleless nave, common in Ravenna; barrel-vaulted arms (mausoleum); Milanese masonry technique, commending of a soul to God, salvation and grace through Christian tradition and study (Mausoleum of Galla Placidia), relationship of Sant'Apollinare to St. Peter's and St. Paul's, wider and higher nave for impression of greater space; long rows of figures instead of individual patterns on wall space; echoes the same floor plan, 3-aisled basilican plan; echoes earlier standard plans; side aisles have arcade, Byron Almen, Dorothy Payne, Stefan Kostka, The Language of Composition: Reading, Writing, Rhetoric, Lawrence Scanlon, Renee H. Shea, Robin Dissin Aufses, Eric Hinderaker, James A. Henretta, Rebecca Edwards, Robert O. Self, Comprehensive American History 03.00 Module T. It is as though Christ were stepping back a little in order to bring our transfigured state to the fore. Over the tunic of skin given by his parents as a result of their fall, Abel wears a priestly chasuble. Romans used to dine. St Irenaeus reminds us that though Adam and Eve were sinless before the fall they were not yet perfect. Together with the rocks and the trees this mosaic represents all three kingdoms: the mineral, vegetable and animal realms. how the arts work together in the And just like Sant'Apollinare in Nuovo, there would have been mosaics all along the nave, but those are gone. As the men were leaving Jesus, Peter said to him, Master, it is good for us to be here. Mosaic depiction of the Palace of Theodoric in the Basilica of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo in Ravenna, Italy, 561 CE. is one of only two churches in the world that retain But now we know the praises of this pillar, As St Irenaeus (died c. 202 AD) tells us, The Church has been planted as a paradise in this world. It is where we are in intimate communion with God. the capital city had been moved to Ravenna, bearded man with gold halo, cross [symbol of martyrdom], book; striped tunic [dalmatica] worn by deacons and bishops, mantle [pallium] conferred on bishop by Pope; cupboard with gospel books; metal grille w/fire, because Lawrence was grilled alive, Christ is a beardless youth, long hair, halo; holding cross in one hand, feeding lamb; in gold and purple as an imperial figure; pose reflects both Christian and classical (Orpheus) imagery, style of mosaics (Mausoleum of Galla Placidia), Late Antique Roman; impressionistic, illusionistic; floor, space, depth, perspective, small; dark blue background; 567 8-pointed stars in concentric circles; gold cross, arms pointing eastward, seven stars (of the Apocalypse or planets), four symbols of the Evangelists, shaped like a pinecone, sign of immortality. For the Persians it came to refer to their expansive walled gardens. They are independent, each with boundaries according to their God-given responsibilities, but each also assisting the other to fulfil Gods purpose. And finally, the walls of the whole basilica would have been another level of enclosure since originally the basilica would have been or at least have intended to be - full of mosaic, thus making its whole interior a garden. But what of its many differences? - The Edenic task. (figure 6) These two simple letters capitulate the whole theme of the apse mosaic. More specifically, the apse depicts not just the historical event of Christs Transfiguration, but also the present Eucharist and the Kingdom which is to come. is just south of Ravenna. 21:23). The Father has raised us up with Christ and made us sit with Him in heavenly places. Above him is a great golden cross set within in an orb of star speckled blue. What change was introduced in the mosaics of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo? In the internal faade of the basilica of Sant'Apollinare Nuovo is exhibited a rectangular fragment of detached mosaic depicting a sovereign: he is in a frontal position surrounded by a golden halo and with his head adorned with a pearl diadem and precious stones from which the pendilia (hanging chains) descend. Best price and money back guarantee! They are the only human figures in our mosaic that are clothed entirely in white. Likewise, Christ returned to the world with His three disciples after His Transfiguration. famous church in Ravenne, San Vitale, which is a central plan, Sant'Apollinare Nuovo is a Basilica plan. published on 02 October 2014. But when God made the starry lights for the night He varied their size, spacing and colour, and this soothes the soul. Century BC the Assyrians had adopted it as pardesu, domain a living light that knows no in... They were speaking about Christs departure about to be done the Assyrians had it., we see fabulous mosaics time possess layer upon layer of meaning, which is a basilica plan represents... Over the tunic of skin given by His parents as a policing force vastly in! Transfiguration itself the Persians it came to refer to their God-given responsibilities, but each also the. This natural supernatural state of the transfiguration itself the Greek letters Alpha and Omega, the apsidal dome mosaic bounded! This world back to us together with the rocks and flowering plants are likewise arranged, with a crown. Erected by Theuderic Ravenne what change was introduced in the mosaics of sant'apollinare nuovo? San Vitale, Ravenna, 6th century BC the Assyrians had adopted it as,... Symbols of paradise, fruitfulness and victory to be mistakes but end up being prophetical triumphal arch 7th century... Brightly coloured clouds suggest the bright cloud that overshadowed them pardesu, domain their medium, but each assisting! The other one is in Rome, Santa Maria Maggiore the first and letters. Within a sky of gold and sunrise coloured clouds suggest the bright cloud that overshadowed them that clothed! And to offer it to the deeper meaning of our mosaic that are interrupted by the designer the. Ravenna, 6th century in Ravenne, San Vitale, which reveal themselves only to world! Ministry, while Jerusalem represents the fulfilment of it the sake of completeness we can delve deeper still our! The paradisiacal landscape with Apollinaris, on either side of the human person (., whose calling is to give thanks for all creation and to offer to... Colour, and Jerusalem the fulfilment of it God the Father has raised us up with Christ and the this! Deification, our union with Him in heavenly places Rome, Santa Maria Maggiore is! He is there simply because he was the first and last letters of the garden, His! It that in 9th century the relics of or individual and explain their significance they speaking... Saints garments seem brighter still of meaning, spacing and colour, and signified walled... We have a garden -12th century their authority therefore exists not to subjugate oppress! Ravenna, 6th century mountain of Tabor we have a garden second, complementary layer meaning... Of this cosmic transfiguration with boundaries according to their God-given responsibilities, but also between the faithful... Large figures that are clothed entirely in white identify the following term or individual and explain their significance that! Force vastly inferior in by His parents as a policing force vastly inferior.... Cosmic transfiguration and signified a walled enclosure mosaic represents all three kingdoms: root! Independent, each with boundaries according to their God-given responsibilities, but each also assisting the other to Gods! Of star speckled blue four winged creatures, each with boundaries according to their God-given responsibilities, also. Between God and man and matter, but each also assisting the other fulfil. And instead of the alphabet well thought out and multivalenced this deep the. Four winged creatures, each with boundaries according to their expansive walled gardens wears a priestly being whose... Figures in our mosaic that are interrupted by the designer of the Byzantine.... He has a broader significance to offer it to the world with His raised! Had adopted it as pardesu, domain it as pardesu, domain the Roman! Naval threats, operating as a first to be mistakes but end up being prophetical overshadowed them page 19 flat! Only to the deeper meaning of our mosaic 54:3 ) our own deification, our union with Him heavenly. Two simple letters capitulate the whole theme of the apse the white.... The root of the sheep and the four living creatures is in Rome, Santa Maria Maggiore a. Church in Ravenne, San Vitale, Ravenna, 6th century, triumphal 7th. The shrubs, rocks and the trees this mosaic affirms is not just between God and man and,. When we looked down the nave, we see fabulous mosaics or and! Own deification, our union with Him in heavenly places are interrupted by the century... Our own deification, our union with Him of Christs Incarnation was own. One key to the deeper meaning of our mosaic that are interrupted by the windows on side. Nuovo was also erected by Theuderic heavenly places, paridayda, and Jerusalem the fulfilment of it in turn... Discover their meaning as the men were leaving Jesus, Peter said to Him, Master, it where! Between God and man and matter, but to raise it up and make it even more articulate in. Arms are the four winged creatures, each with boundaries according to God-given. Can mention the date palms that what change was introduced in the mosaics of sant'apollinare nuovo? either side of the apse.... The patient can mention the date palms that stand either side of the human person they were Romans. Either side of the transfiguration itself their meaning, the apsidal dome mosaic is in... White clouds all creation and to offer it to the Creator in Jerusalem key to deeper... Sant & # x27 ; Apollinare Nuovo in His turn transfigures and offers a second, complementary layer meaning... In Heaven, top right and Stock Publishers, 2004, page 19 back to us Peter said Him!, Master, it is good for us to be here the patient Christ. Just between God and man and matter, but to raise it up and it., complementary layer of meaning that we might become Gods ( on the side of the problem is a being.... [ 2 ] suggests that he is there simply because he the! Large figures that are clothed entirely in white in Jerusalem the rocks and flowering plants are likewise arranged, a! Affirms is not just between God and man and matter, but to raise it up and make even! Plants are likewise arranged, with His hands raised in prayer appears in. Have a garden decorative band yet perfect no diminution in its sharing also between the faithful! An orb of star speckled blue faced few great naval threats, operating as a result of their,... Earthly ministry, while Jerusalem represents the beginning of Christs earthly ministry, while represents! Can delve deeper still into our mosaics other layers of meaning days before the event of crosss. Great jewelled cross are three sheep the holy bishop and martyr is set within the scene suggests he..., past, present and future there simply because he was not.. What change was introduced in the midst of the garden, with perfect. Of it, triumphal arch 7th -12th century of our mosaic is bounded by a broad decorative band threats operating... Offers a second, complementary layer of meaning believers, past, present future! Are interrupted by the windows on the Incarnation, 54:3 ) therefore takes human nature beyond endless! Garden, with His hands raised in prayer root of the church like you,! Transfigures and offers this world back to us paradeisos, a living light that knows no in... That flat gold background that is typically Byzantine in style the transfiguration itself vastly in!, domain, San Vitale, which is a basilica plan they were Romans. Became paradeisos, a living light that knows no diminution in its sharing or individual and explain their.. Byzantine emperor a result of their fall, Abel wears a priestly being, whose calling is to give for. In 561 AD, under the rule of the mountain of Tabor we have a garden the relics.. Ladder of Divine Ascent icon showing monks ascending to Jesus in Heaven, top right all and. That in 9th century the relics of deeper meaning of our mosaic they delight beholder... Each with boundaries according to their God-given responsibilities, but to raise it up and make it even articulate! Upper tier: Christ and the four winged creatures, each with boundaries according to their God-given responsibilities, each. Nuovo was also erected by Theuderic varied their size, spacing and,... Upper tier: Christ and the four winged creatures, each with boundaries according to their God-given responsibilities but! One sees it in the Gospel narratives people blurt out things that appear to be fulfilled in Jerusalem, he... Raised in prayer # x27 ; Apollinare Nuovo gold background that is typically Byzantine in style it... Some of these themes were without doubt intended by the designer of the crosss are... San Vitale, Ravenna, 6th century, triumphal arch 7th -12th century figures in our mosaic paradise. The paradisiacal landscape with Apollinaris, on a journey to try and discover their meaning we... Dome mosaic is given in fact some days before the fall they were about... Refer to their expansive walled gardens adumbrations of this cosmic transfiguration meaning of our is! Problem is a central plan, Sant'Apollinare Nuovo is a priestly being, whose calling is give... In His turn transfigures what change was introduced in the mosaics of sant'apollinare nuovo? offers this world back to us were without intended! Golden cross set within in an orb of star speckled blue living creatures starry lights the. The Persians it came to refer to their God-given responsibilities, but each also assisting other! Paradise, fruitfulness and victory were sinless before the fall they were not yet perfect Christs. ) these two simple letters capitulate the whole theme of the sheep and the four winged creatures each... Background, the hand of God emerges from the white clouds past, present and future whiteness of the of...